Category: Getting Started ¤ Author: Dani Weinberg ¤ Title: Getting Started ¤ Welcome, Trisha! It really is fun, isn't it! > > But, being brand new at this I have a hard time not saying ANYTHING while I am shaping a new behavior.>> On training "without saying anything," here are a few thoughts. First of all, you can smile - and that starts to feel like you're "talking" to your dogs. In fact, you *are* - or, at least, communicating in a more general sense of the word. I've noticed how little J&P trainers smile when they're training or showing. Next, there's nothing wrong with a little friendly chatter to the dog ("How did you do that, get that treat? Can you do that again? Do you remember? Can you figure it out? Of course you can! You're so clever!"). I do a lot of that when I'm training, and I know others do too. I think of smiling and chattering as "incompatible behaviors" with giving premature verbal cues, so they can be helpful to what some people call a "crossover trainer" (which is what many of us on the list are, having grown up in J&P and moved into OC). >Plus, both dogs are still unsure about the shaping part of the training because they do not know to offer behaviors yet (they do LOVE getting treats for things, and not getting any negative reinforcement/corrections, however). A common early problem with "crossover" dogs. We have to poke and prod them a little into being creative. >I have shaped going and touching a target/plate (which will eventually be to solidify hitting contact zones in Agility), and they are progressing nicely. I think it worked so well because they naturally were curious as soon as I put the plate on the floor. But I seem to keep hitting a brick wall when I try to start shaping something new and they start staring at me for a few minutes on end, sitting perfectly still. Then I give them a command they already know (beg, down, etc.) and they do it instantly. A good way to get their creative juices (and yours!) flowing is to start shaping spontaneous behaviors that they offer - anything at all such as ear twitches, head turns, scratching, sighing, pawing, play-bowing, stretching, pushing a ball around - and to start teaching them tricks that you choose based on their own natural behaviors. For example, if your dog frequently rolls over, you teach Rollover! If she does a lot of paw-lifting, you teach Shake or Wave or High Five out of that natural behavior. And you can always build on the target training you've already started successfully. Targeting is a wonderfully versatile behavior. It's good to start this whole process by getting as far away as you can from formal, serious "obedience" behaviors - or in fact anything they already know. Oh, and BTW, when they stare at you, don't stare back! You'll just freeze them in position. Move yourself and your dog will move too - thereby offering you a behavior to "catch" with the clicker. >Dani, >It often works that way, but never trust "single trial learning" when working with something so crucial -- The real goal is to get to the point where the reinforcers are all positive, and that takes a bunch of repetitions! >Regards, >Gary p.s. You just broke a bunch of dictums of modern psychology – you heretic, you!